Wrestling Mayhem Show 993: Pie Hard with Tony Kincaid

About this Episode

Wrestling Mayhem Show 993: Tony Kincaid vs. The Inevitable Pie

Monday nights don’t usually look like this—RAW is on, the group chat energy is turned up, and the Wrestling Mayhem Show crew is doing what it does best: tracking the weird little signals that become big wrestling conversations.

First up: the buzz around The IInspiration showing up in AEW. The debate isn’t whether they belong (they do), it’s about the choice—dropping a moment that big on a house show instead of television, and whether the modern “social media hidden gem” approach actually builds hype or just frustrates people who wanted the pop on-screen. 

From there, the WWE machine gives everyone a new toy to argue about: the mystery box. The crew turns it into a full-on challenge: send in your best “realistic but funniest” answer, and you might score a Mayhem Mania advantage. 

Then the conversation takes a sharp left into the business side of fandom: talk of a WrestleMania weekend Vegas watch-party blackout and what that means for fans who still want to be part of the spectacle without dropping stadium-ticket money. 

And finally—because wrestling always delivers the real main event—Tony Kincaid joins the show with a cloud hanging over him: after multiple snow-powered escapes, he’s (allegedly) finally getting pied at RWA Fury this weekend. The crew relives how it started, how the weather kept saving him, and why the locker room might be the real danger if he tries to dodge it again. 

What We Learned this week? AAA is bringing full telenovela energy, MJF’s understanding of the art/business line is still elite, and sometimes the wrestling gods will absolutely troll you—quietly, even—if your kid’s sleeping in the next room.